Jams & Jellies · Autumn Comfort

Pumpkin Butter

Recalling the taste of grandma’s best pumpkin pie, this creamy spread is heavenly with gingerbread or waffles and ice cream.

5.0 · 1 review

$8.75

Size

8 oz

  • In stock · ships in 2–3 business days from Utopia, Texas
  • Free shipping on orders over $65
  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan
  • Gluten-free
  • Dairy-free

Warm, comforting flavor

Recalling the taste of grandma’s best pumpkin pie, this creamy spread is full of cinnamon-spiced comfort. Handcrafted in small batches, our Pumpkin Butter is as at home in your baking as it is on the breakfast table, adding a cozy touch to everyday favorites.

Try it like this

  • Spread on fresh bread with clotted cream or mascarpone for a special treat
  • Spoon into plain or vanilla yogurt for a creamy, spiced snack
  • Blend into a smoothie with banana and milk for a fall-inspired drink
  • Bake as a substitute for oil or butter in cakes, breads, and muffins
  • Top gingerbread, waffles, or ice cream for a cozy dessert

Recipes

Nutrition Facts
About 15 servings per container
Serving size 1 Tbsp. (18g)
Amount per serving Calories 25
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 0g 0%
Saturated Fat 0g 0%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg 0%
Sodium 0mg 0%
Total Carbohydrate 6g 2%
Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
Total Sugars 6g
Includes 5g Added Sugars 10%
Protein 0g
  • Vitamin D 0mcg 0%
  • Calcium 10mg 0%
  • Iron 0.2mg 2%
  • Potassium 40mg 0%

*The % Daily Value tells you how much a nutrient in a serving of food contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice.

What is inside

Ingredients

Pumpkin, cane sugar, water, molasses, apple juice base (apple juice concentrate, filtered water, citric acid, ascorbic acid [vitamin C], natural flavors), citric acid, spices

Dietary

  • Vegetarian
  • Vegan
  • Gluten-free
  • Dairy-free

Allergens

Made in a facility that also handles tree nuts. Always check the jar label.

Storage

Shelf stable until opened. Refrigerate after opening and use within three months.

  • 5 stars: 1 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
L
Leah

I get this every single year! I highly recommend it. It’s the best pumpkin butter out there.

Questions

What does Pumpkin Butter taste like?
It has a smooth pumpkin flavor with the warm, cozy character people look for in fall—ideal when you want pumpkin without the heaviness of a dessert filling.
What can I do with Pumpkin Butter besides spread it on toast?
Swirl it into oatmeal, yogurt or pancake batter, use it in muffins or quick bread, or spoon it over waffles and pancakes for an instant fall breakfast.
What pairs well with Pumpkin Butter?
Try it with cream cheese, mascarpone, pecans, apples or warm baking spices. Those flavors complement pumpkin without overpowering it.
What is the difference between jam, jelly, preserves, and fruit butter?
Our jams are made with a high density of fruits that are simmered with sugar, then gently puréed into a smooth, thick texture, with some small pieces of fruit. Preserves are made with whole or larger pieces of fruit, suspended in a rich syrup. Jellies are made primarily with fruit juice to make a smooth, light and refreshing taste, and we often suspend juicy morsels of fruit and peppers inside to make them extra delicious. Butters are cooked down and puréed until very smooth and concentrated; despite the name, they contain no dairy butter.
Which jams are your best-sellers?
Our jams and jellies have a very loyal following! In order, our best sellers are: Jalapeño Jelly, Fredericksburg Peach Jam, Brazos River Blackberry Jam, Texas Red Plum Jam, Strawberry Almond Jam, Lemon Fig Jam, Old Austin Apricot Jam, Peach Amaretto & Pecan Jam, Natural Strawberry Jam, East Texas Blueberry Jam, Pineapple Jalapeño Jelly, Cherry Preserves, Raspberry Jam.
What jam should I put on a cheese or charcuterie board?
Our jams make perfect partners for cheese and charcuterie, and we have a host of wonderful flavor combinations to share. Check out our Cheese and Charcuterie pairings page for our top tips! Some highlights are Old Austin Apricot Jam with nutty parmesan, Lemon Fig with goat cheese and prosciutto, and Raspberry Jalapeño Jam with brie and ham.
How much fruit is in your jams?
We put a lot of fruit in every jam we make: by volume, far more than sugar. For example, in our Fredericksburg Peach jam we have 1.3 cups of juicy peaches in every jar; for our Country Apple Butter we simmer 1/2 lb of apples per jar. Our Strawberry Almond Jam has a cup of strawberries and our East Texas Blueberry Jam almost a cup of blueberries. Sugar is often listed first on our labels as it is a very heavy ingredient, but in terms of the amount of ingredients, we will always put as much fruit in as we can!
Do you have any jams with no added sugar?
Yes. New Canaan Farms makes Natural Peach and Natural Strawberry Jam, which have no added sugar and are sweetened with fruit juice. For current ingredients, nutrition, and dietary information, check the individual product page or jar label.
What are the main ingredients in your jams?
Fruit, sugar, citrus pectin and citric acid are the main ingredients for our classic jams. When we have additional flavors there are more ingredients, and we aim to use fresh produce as much as we can. For example, we flavor our fig jam with a fresh slice of lemon to create Lemon Fig Jam, we use fresh serrano peppers for our Cranberry Pepper Jam, and fresh jalapeños for Raspberry Jalapeño Jam.
How long do unopened jams and jellies last?
Most of our jams have a shelf life of two years, unopened. Our Natural Strawberry and Peach jams, and our Pecan Honey Crème, have an unopened shelf life of 12 months. Once opened, store in the refrigerator and consume within 3 months (this should be easy to do!)
Do jams and jellies need to be refrigerated after opening?
Yes. Once opened, refrigerate jarred jams and jellies and follow the storage directions on the label.
Can I keep an unopened jar in the pantry?
Yes. Unopened shelf-stable jars can be kept in the pantry or another cool, dry place until opening, subject to the best-by information on the jar.
Are your jams and jellies gluten-free?
All of our jams are gluten free and vegan, as are the majority of our products. We focus on making our products with whole foods, and minimize artificial preservatives. For specific product ingredients and nutrition facts, please check the relevant product page.
Are New Canaan Farms jams made in a nut-free facility?
No. We use pecans and almonds in some products, so our facility is not nut-free. Our kettles and cooking equipment are thoroughly steam-cleaned and sanitized between cooks to avoid any cross-contamination, but anyone with an allergy should check the label and make decisions appropriate to their needs.

On your table

Tag @NewCanaanFarms on Instagram to join us!

Posts open on Instagram in a new tab.